• Mashup Religion
  • Jonymac Studio
  • The West End Rhythm Kings

Otherwise Thinking

~ a blog by John McClure

Otherwise Thinking

Monthly Archives: January 2013

Epiphany as Sermon Form

03 Thursday Jan 2013

Posted by John McClure in Musings, Views from the Street

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

Bible and Preaching, epiphany, Eugene Lowry, homiletic method, homiletical plot, John Dominic Crossan, lectionary, lectionary preaching, parable, parabolic communication, plot, preaching, sermon form, sermon illustration

How does one preach “epiphany” in an “epiphany-like” way? And how does a preacher keep epiphany alive throughout the year in one’s preaching?

Epiphany, in one translation, means “manifestation.” It is the manifestation or  “showing forth” of God’s glory and divinity in Jesus Christ. The word also translates as a sudden insight into the essential meaning of something, usually initiated by some ordinary occurrence or experience. Epiphanic truth, therefore, is truth that arrives as a sudden insight. It is the endpoint of significant delay, and is the hidden object of great anticipation. And its arrival is unexpected because it is not grand and overstated,  but shows itself within the ordinary stuff of life – like a child in a manger.

Many of the best sermons are “epiphanic.” They delay the arrival of the sermon’s meaning or deepest “truth,” and then, within the anticipation established by that delay, “manifest” that truth by means of the ordinary – in an image of grace, mercy, hope in spite of despair, love, or joy within the fabric of everyday life.

Eugene Lowry’s “homiletical plot” is one such sermon form. In 1980 Eugene L. Lowry published a very popular little book entitled The Homiletical Plot: The Sermon as Narrative Art Form. In this book, he created what is now commonly known as the Lowry Loop to describe the way that a simple narrative plot functions in a sermon. The first part of the loop involves upsetting the equilibrium. An enigma is presented that energizes the sermon’s forward movement: something is wrong that needs fixing, something is out of balance that needs restoration, something is missing that needs finding, something is confusing that needs clarification, etc. This problem is deepened in the second, and downward part of the loop, called analyzing the discrepancy. Like a good plot line, the sermon goes deeper into the problem at hand, complicating the issue and creating a heightened concern among listeners. At this point, the sermon reaches the bottom of the loop in which the preacher discloses the clue to resolution. This is the decisive turning point in the plot. The gospel brings a reversal or “aha” that begins to move the loop upward toward resolution. This, in effect, is the “epiphany” or manifestation of gospel truth that is the heart of the sermon. This “clue” is often taken from ordinary human experience – a picture of “God with us.” From here the sermon moves upward in the fourth part of the loop, experiencing the gospel. The preacher fleshes out the good news of the gospel and its meaning. Finally, at the end of the loop, the sermon helps the congregation anticipate the consequences. The preacher unpacks fully the implications of the sermon’s message for the living of life. In order the help preachers remember each aspect of the loop, Lowry created a little memory device for each part of the loop: Oops!, Ugh!, Aha!, Whee!, and Yeah! The “Aha!”  is the epiphany at the heart of the sermon.

Another epiphany-form is parable. Parabolic communication is designed to introduce as an “epiphany” some form of contradiction and unexpected irresolution where reconciliation and order are otherwise assumed. According to John Dominic Crossan, parable is the polar opposite of myth and functions as an agent of deconstruction, interruption, and change. Many parables take what listeners expect to hear and reverse it. In this form of communication, therefore, the epiphany in the sermon is some form of reversal of listener expectation. For instance, in the New Testament story of the Pharisee and the publican we assume that the original listener expected the Pharisee’s prayer to be accepted by God and the publican’s to be rejected. In the story, however, the opposite occurs, opening the story to new meanings. Epiphany within parabolic preaching is iconoclastic, introducing contradictions or unexpected tensions where none previously existed.

So, how does one preach “epiphany” in an “epiphany-like” way? In two ways, mainly. First, by acting like a storyteller and delaying the arrival of one’s “meaning” in the sermon – and allowing it to arrive as a “clue” embedded within the ordinary fabric of human life. Second, by interrupting and reversing listener expectations; showing how God’s ways cannot be “storied” at all, but often arrive in entirely unexpected and counter-intuitive ways.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 192 other subscribers

John McClure

Recent Posts

  • My Sermon Organization Method: Sermon Sequencing and the “Multi-Track Sermon”
  • Transcript: Jeremiah Wright’s 9/11 Sermon
  • Getting Sermon Feedback
  • Sermon Logic in a Hyperlink Generation
  • Multimedia Preaching
  • Humor and Preaching
  • Extemporaneous Preaching and the Art of Improvisation
  • Long-Range Preaching
  • The Frustrated Preacher
  • This Sabbatical: Trying On A Few (Old) Shoes

Categories

  • Connecting the Dots
  • improvisation
  • Musings
  • Views from the Street
  • Who is this?

Archives

  • July 2020
  • September 2016
  • July 2014
  • December 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011

Buy Speaking Together and With God

Speaking Together and With God: Liturgy and Communicative Ethics

Buy Under the Oak Tree

Under the Oak Tree

Buy Mashup Religion

Buy Otherwise Preaching

Buy Preaching Words

Buy Claiming Theology in the Pulpit

Buy The Four Codes of Preaching

Buy The Roundtable Pulpit

Buy Listening to Listeners: Homiletical Case Studies

Download Telling the Truth: Preaching about Sexual and Domestic Violence (free)

Buy Best Advice for Preaching

Buy New Proclamation: Year C; Advent Through Holy Week

Blogroll

  • I P Prospective
  • Leslie Rodríguez Photography Blog
  • Los Rodriguez Life
  • Mashup Religion
  • Ministry Matters
  • Peer Pressure is Forever
  • Rock and Theology

Websites

  • Academy of Homiletics
  • Captured by Leslie: Leslie Rodriguez Photography
  • Homiletic: A Journal of Religious Speech Communication
  • Otherwise Thinking facebook page

RSS Mashup Religion

  • Sherry Cothran’s “Strange Woman”: Popular Music as Parahomiletic
  • New Blog about Artists in my Recording Studio
  • Para-homiletics and video games
  • From "Air Guitar" to "Air Preaching"
  • Wound 3: The Wounding of “Spatial” Desire
  • II. The Second of Five Wounded Desires: The Wounding of Ethical Desire
  • I. The First of Five Wounds/Five Desires: the Wounding of Our Desire for God
  • Caveats
  • Join me in a theological mashup
  • Musicians Might Learn a Thing or Two from Theologians

Otherwise Thinking

  • RSS - Posts
  • RSS - Comments

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Otherwise Thinking
    • Join 192 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Otherwise Thinking
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar